Can I Upgrade My Engagement Ring Later? Your Options Explained

Your engagement ring is one of the most meaningful pieces of jewelry you’ll ever own. But that doesn’t mean it has to stay the same forever.

Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, reaching a new milestone, or simply ready for a bigger diamond — yes, you can upgrade your engagement ring.

At Doland Jewelers, we make the upgrade process simple, thoughtful, and flexible. We’ll walk you through your options, explain what’s possible, and handle any alterations with care and craftsmanship.

Let’s explore how it works.

💎 Option 1: Upgrade Just the Diamond

The most common request we see is a diamond upgrade. Whether you want more size, better clarity, or a different shape, we’ll help you find the perfect new center stone.

If your current setting is compatible, we’ll swap in the new diamond.

But in some cases, upgrading the diamond requires minor alterations to your original ring — especially if:

• The new stone is a different shape or size
• The setting prongs need to be rebuilt or reinforced
• The overall proportions need adjusting for visual balance

This is where Doland’s truly shines. Our on-site professional jewelers make these alterations the right way — ensuring your ring looks seamless, stays secure, and lasts for years to come.

🔁 Option 2: Trade In or Sell Your Original Ring

Some customers decide they want a completely new ring — new setting, new stone, new style.

In that case, you have the option to:

• Trade in your original ring toward a new one
• Sell back the original diamond and use the value toward your next piece

We’ll give you an honest assessment of the value and make sure you’re comfortable with the process. No pressure — just expert guidance from a local jeweler you can trust.

💖 Option 3: Repurpose the Original into a New Piece

This is one of our favorite options — and a truly meaningful one.

If you’re upgrading your ring but want to hold onto the original, we can help you transform it into something new:

• A pendant that keeps your first diamond close to your heart
• A right-hand ring to celebrate a personal milestone
• A custom piece made with the metal or accent stones from your original band

You keep the memories — just in a new form that reflects where you are now.

💬 Real Stories from Real Customers

“We upgraded my wife’s diamond for our 15th anniversary, and they turned her original ring into a necklace for our daughter. She cried when we gave it to her.”
— Brian D., Dubuque

“I was nervous to mess with the original, but Doland’s made it feel easy. They walked me through every option and even showed me a CAD rendering of the new piece before making it.”
— Mia S., Davenport

🔧 Expert Jewelers On Site = Peace of Mind

Alterations and upgrades should never feel risky. That’s why Doland Jewelers proudly does the work in-house, with trained bench jewelers who treat your ring like it’s their own.

We’ll explain every step, show you examples, and even overnight diamonds for you to view — with no obligation to buy.

💍 Thinking About an Upgrade?

Whether you’re ready to trade in, repurpose your original ring, or just want to explore your options — we’re here to help.

Visit us in Dubuque or Davenport, or book an appointment for a pressure-free conversation with one of our trusted experts.

✨ New diamond, same love story.

Let’s make your next chapter unforgettable — and wearable.