Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamonds: Which Should You Choose?

If you're shopping for a diamond, chances are you've come across two main options: natural diamonds and lab-grown diamonds. At Doland Jewelers, we help customers navigate this decision every day — and we understand it can feel overwhelming at first.

Let’s break down the facts so you can choose with confidence.

💎 What’s the Difference Between Lab-Grown and Natural Diamonds?

Natural diamonds are formed deep within the Earth over billions of years. They’re rare, timeless, and come with a sense of wonder that only nature can create.

Lab-grown diamonds are created in a controlled environment using high-tech equipment that replicates the Earth’s natural diamond-forming process. They’re physically, chemically, and visually identical to natural diamonds — the only real difference is their origin.

💰 Price: Lab-Grown = More Diamond for Your Dollar

Lab-grown diamonds typically cost much less than their natural counterparts. That means you might get a larger carat size or higher quality for the same budget.

But here's the trade-off: lab-grown diamonds don’t retain value in the same way. Resale and trade-in options are limited.

At Doland Jewelers, we tell it like it is:
If your budget is tight and size is your top priority, lab-grown can be a great option. But if you're thinking long-term or want to preserve value, a natural diamond is still the classic choice.

♻️ Sustainability & Ethics

Both options can be ethically sourced — and we only work with trusted suppliers who follow responsible practices.

Lab-grown diamonds are often marketed as more eco-friendly. However, they still require a lot of energy to produce. Natural diamonds support local communities and jobs, particularly in Africa and Canada, when mined responsibly.

If sustainability is important to you, we’re happy to show you conflict-free natural options and certified lab-grown stones, side by side.

🔁 The Doland Upgrade Promise (Only for Natural Diamonds)

One of the biggest reasons our customers choose natural diamonds is our lifetime upgrade policy.

✅Any natural diamond or natural diamond stud earrings you purchase from Doland Jewelers can be upgraded anytime in the future.
✅ You’ll receive full credit toward your new stone — just spend at least double the original price.

Whether you're upgrading an engagement ring or celebrating a milestone anniversary, this policy makes it easy to grow with your diamond.

(Sorry — this policy doesn’t apply to lab-grown diamonds due to their volatile market value.)

💬 What Our Customers Say

We’re proud to be known as knowledgeable, honest, and approachable. Whether you're a diamond expert or just starting your search, our friendly staff will guide you without pressure.

“They answered every question without making me feel dumb — and I never felt rushed. I walked out knowing I made the right choice.”
— Jenna L., Dubuque

“We looked everywhere, but Doland’s made it so easy. We ended up with a beautiful natural diamond that we can upgrade in the future.”
— Marcus D., Davenport

🛍️ So… Which Diamond Should You Choose?

There’s no wrong answer — only the one that fits your budget, values, and long-term goals.

👉 If you want maximum sparkle for less and aren't concerned with resale: consider a lab-grown.
👉 If you want lasting value, upgrade potential, and timeless romance: a natural diamond is still the gold standard.

At Doland Jewelers, we’re here to make this process easy and enjoyable — not stressful. Come in and compare stones side by side. Ask all the questions. We'll walk you through it, just like we've done for thousands of happy customers since 1986.

💡 Ready to Start Shopping?

Visit us in Dubuque or Davenport, or schedule a private appointment for personalized help with no pressure.